Disclosure: Grounded in Thyme earns a small commission from some affiliate links at no extra cost. Full Disclosures & Disclaimers.

Everything Bagel Spice Mix Recipe: Cheaper, Healthier & Better Than Store-Bought!

Name: Everything Bagel Seasoning
Prep time: 5 min
Ingredients: 2 Tbsp sesame seeds (white or a mix of white and black); 2 Tbsp poppy seeds; 2 Tbsp dried minced onion (or dried onion flakes); 2 Tbsp dried minced garlic (or garlic flakes); 1 Tbsp flaky sea salt (such as Maldon or coarse kosher salt (reduce to 2 tsp if you prefer less salty))

If you’ve ever sprinkled everything bagel seasoning on avocado toast, eggs, or popcorn and wondered why it’s so addictive, you’re not alone. That crunchy, savory blend of sesame seeds, poppy seeds, garlic, onion, and salt is a game-changer. But buying it pre-made can cost $5–$10 for a small jar. What if I told you this everything bagel spice mix recipe is ridiculously easy, costs pennies per batch, and is way healthier? In this guide, we’ll dive into why making your own is a smarter (and more flavorful) choice, plus the simple recipe you can whip up in minutes.

Why Make Your Own Everything Bagel Spice Mix?

Let’s be real—store-bought everything bagel seasoning is convenient, but it’s often overpriced and loaded with extras you don’t need. Here’s why this everything bagel spice mix recipe beats the jar every time:

Huge Cost Savings: A typical 4-oz jar at the grocery store costs $5–$8. This homemade version? Less than $2 for the same amount (or even less if you buy spices in bulk). Sesame seeds and poppy seeds are the priciest at ~$0.50–$1 per Tbsp, but everything else (like garlic/onion powder and salt) is basically free from your pantry. One batch makes ½ cup—enough for months of sprinkling—and scales up easily.
Healthier Choice: Commercial blends can sneak in anti-caking agents (like silicon dioxide), excess sodium (up to 300mg per tsp), or even sugar to boost shelf life. Your homemade everything bagel spice mix recipe uses pure, whole-food ingredients—no fillers, no preservatives. You control the salt level (perfect for low-sodium diets), and the fresh spices deliver more antioxidants and flavor. Plus, it’s naturally gluten-free, vegan, and keto-friendly.
Customizable Flavor: Store versions are one-note. With this recipe, tweak the ratios—more garlic for punch, less salt for heart health, or add dried herbs like dill for a twist.
Eco-Friendly Perk: Skip the plastic packaging. Store in reusable mason jars for zero waste.

Making your own isn’t just thrifty—it’s empowering. In 2026, with grocery prices still high, this small swap saves real money without sacrificing taste.

Everything Bagel Spice Mix Recipe

Prep Time: 5 minutes Total Time: 5 minutes Servings: 24 (1 tsp each) Yield: ~½ cup

Ingredients

2 Tbsp sesame seeds (white or a mix of white and black)
2 Tbsp poppy seeds
2 Tbsp dried minced onion (or onion flakes)
2 Tbsp dried minced garlic (or garlic flakes)
1 Tbsp flaky sea salt (or coarse kosher salt – reduce to 2 tsp for low-sodium)

Instructions

In a small bowl, combine sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried minced onion, dried minced garlic, and flaky sea salt.
Stir well with a spoon until evenly mixed.
Transfer to an airtight jar or spice container (a small mason jar works perfectly).
Store in a cool, dark place for up to 6 months. Shake or stir before each use to redistribute the ingredients.

To Use

Sprinkle generously on avocado toast, bagels with cream cheese, hard-boiled eggs, roasted vegetables, hummus, or popcorn.
Mix into softened cream cheese or sour cream for an instant dip.
Use as a seasoning for homemade crackers, bread dough, or roasted nuts.

Notes

Salt level: Flaky sea salt gives the best texture and crunch, but if you’re sensitive to salt, start with 2 tsp and adjust.
Variations: Add 1 tsp dried onion powder or garlic powder for extra punch, or a pinch of black pepper for subtle heat.
Gluten-free & vegan: Naturally yes!
Storage tip: Keep in a glass jar away from moisture to maintain crispness.

This homemade everything bagel spice mix recipe is so much fresher and more flavorful than store-bought—and it costs pennies to make. No fillers, no mystery ingredients—just pure, crunchy goodness.

Cost Breakdown: How Much You Really Save

Let’s crunch the numbers. Bulk spices from Costco or Amazon cost:

Sesame seeds: $0.50 for 2 Tbsp
Poppy seeds: $0.60 for 2 Tbsp
Dried onion/garlic: $0.20 each
Salt: $0.10 Total: $1.60 for ½ cup (24 tsp servings). Store-bought: $5–$8 for similar amount. That’s a 70–80% savings per batch. Make it once a month, and you save $40–$70 a year—easy money for coffee or seeds for your garden.

Health Benefits: Why Homemade Wins

Beyond savings, the health perks are huge. Store blends often have 200–300mg sodium per tsp—too much for heart health. Your version? Control it to 100mg or less. Fresh spices mean more antioxidants (from garlic/onion) and anti-inflammatory compounds (from seeds). It’s a small switch that makes everyday meals healthier, especially for families watching salt or additives.

Fun Ways to Use It

Sprinkle on salads for crunch, mix into yogurt dips, rim cocktail glasses, or bake into bread. It’s versatile and kid-approved—my family loves it on buttered popcorn for movie nights.

In conclusion, this everything bagel spice mix recipe is a simple win: cheaper, healthier, and endlessly useful. Ditch the jar and make your own—you’ll wonder why you ever bought it.

Ready to mix up a batch?

Everything Bagel Seasoning

Here’s a simple, delicious Everything Bagel Seasoning recipe. It’s the classic blend—savory, crunchy, and perfect for sprinkling on avocado toast, eggs, popcorn, roasted veggies, homemade crackers, or even mixing into cream cheese. Everything Bagel Seasoning Prep Time: 5 minutes Total Time: 5 minutes Servings: 24 (1 tsp each) Yield: ~½ cup

Prep Time 5

Serving Size 24

Ingredients

2 Tbsp sesame seeds white or a mix of white and black
2 Tbsp poppy seeds
2 Tbsp dried minced onion or dried onion flakes
2 Tbsp dried minced garlic or garlic flakes
1 Tbsp flaky sea salt such as Maldon or coarse kosher salt (reduce to 2 tsp if you prefer less salty)

Instructions

In a small bowl, combine all ingredients: sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried minced onion, dried minced garlic, and flaky sea salt.
Stir well with a spoon until evenly mixed.
Transfer to an airtight jar or spice container (a small mason jar works beautifully).
Store in a cool, dry place for up to 6 months. Shake or stir before each use to redistribute the ingredients.
To Use
Sprinkle generously on avocado toast, bagels with cream cheese, hard-boiled eggs, roasted vegetables, hummus, or popcorn.
Mix into softened cream cheese or sour cream for an instant dip.
Use as a seasoning for homemade crackers, bread dough, or roasted nuts.

Notes

Salt level: Flaky sea salt gives the best texture and crunch, but if you’re sensitive to salt, start with 2 tsp and adjust.
Variations: Add 1 tsp dried onion powder or garlic powder for extra punch, or a pinch of black pepper for subtle heat.
Gluten-free & vegan: Naturally yes!
Storage tip: Keep in a glass jar away from moisture to maintain crispness.

This homemade everything bagel seasoning is so much fresher and more flavorful than store-bought—and it costs pennies to make. No fillers, no mystery ingredients—just pure, crunchy goodness.
Enjoy sprinkling it on everything! What’s your favorite way to use everything bagel seasoning? Drop it in the comments—I read every one!